1991 Draft Redo - What Should've Happened
Southern Miss QB Brett Favre
Southern Miss QB Brett Favre
Posted Apr 23, 2009

What should each team have done in the first round of the 1991 NFL Draft?

Draft Redo ... 1991

How should the drafts have gone?

By Pete Fiutak 

2006 Draft Redo | 2005 Draft Redo | 2004 Draft Redo | 2003 Draft Redo
2002 Draft Redo | 2001 Draft Redo | 2000 Draft Redo | 1999 Draft Redo
1998 Draft Redo | 1997 Draft Redo | 1996 Draft Redo | 1995 Draft Redo  
1994 Draft Redo | 1993 Draft Redo | 1992 Draft Redo | 1991 Draft Redo
1990 Draft Redo | 1989 Draft Redo

Here's a look at past NFL drafts looking to see what each team needed, who they all took in the first round, and in hindsight, who should've gone based on how their pro careers turned out (forgetting about proper coaching and other circumstances).

If each team could draft knowing what we all know now and not taking future drafts into account, this is how the first round should've gone. There were 27 picks in the first round of the 1991 draft. In parentheses is the round the player was actually taken.

Who Went How the Draft Should've Gone
1. Dallas Cowboys
Russell Maryland, DT Miami
OT Erik Williams (3rd), Central St (OH)
Dallas Cowboys
While Brett Favre turned out to be the premier player in the 1991 draft, Dallas already had a young Troy Aikman. The genius of the Cowboy drafts in the early 1990s wasn't in the early round picks, it was the mid to late rounders and even though Russell Maryland was a decent player, Erik Williams was the premier offensive lineman of the decade. With Aikman and budding star Emmitt Smith, it's time to make the line a monster. Originally, Jerry and Jimmy traded up (New England originally had the first pick) to take Rocket Ismail, but the Irish star couldn't come to terms with Dallas and bolted for Canada before the draft.
2. Cleveland Browns
Eric Turner, DT UCLA
QB Brett Favre (2nd), Southern Miss
Atlanta Falcons
Bernie Kosar isn't the player he once was; who'd be better to give pointers to a young gunslinger? You don't think the Dog Pound would've liked Favre?
3. Atlanta Falcons
Bruce Pickens, CB Nebraska
RB Ricky Watters (2nd), Notre Dame
San Francisco 49ers
Atlanta's leading rusher in 1990 was Steve Broussard with 454 yards. Imagine a speedster like Watters on turf catching passes out of the backfield from Chris Miller in the run n' shoot.
4. Denver Broncos
Mike Croel, LB Nebraska
CB Aeneas Williams, (3rd) Southern
Arizona Cardinals
The Broncos had enough offense and Croel was a decent player for a few years, but Denver could've taken Williams and plugged in the fringe Hall of Fame candidate for ten-plus years.
5. Los Angeles Rams
Todd Lyght, DB Notre Dame
DT Ted Washington,  (1st) Louisville
San Francisco 49ers
The Rams have a ton of offense with QB Jim Everett and a great power running game, but they need to stop the pass and stuff the run. It might take a year or two, but Washington will be a great, but ornery, run stopper for the next decade.
6. Arizona Cardinals
Eric Swann, DT no college
WR Herman Moore, (1st) Virginia 
Detroit Lions
Swann was almost a dominant star, but he never materialized in Phoenix. Roy Green and Ernie Jones just aren't the weapons to surround Timm Rosenbach with. While the Cardinals need a running back more than a receiver, Moore is too good to pass up. 
7. Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Charles McRae, OT Tennessee
WR Ed McCaffrey, (3rd) Stanford
New York Giants
McCaffrey has never received his due as a top receiver, but few have been steadier over the last decade. Mark Carrier and Bruce Hill just aren't the top shelf receivers that'll help Vinny Testaverde. The Bucs desperately need a running back but there aren't any in this draft.
8. Philadelphia Eagles
OT Antone Davis, OT Tennessee
DT Russell Maryland, (1st) Miami
Dallas Cowboys
The Eagles could really use a running back and a top offensive lineman, but there aren't any out there worth the No. 8 pick. Maryland was a solid producer and will be sorely needed for a team that'll lose Jerome Brown and Reggie White in the coming years.
9. San Diego Chargers
Stanley Richard, DB Texas
DB Eric Turner, (1st) UCLA
Cleveland Browns
Richard wasn't worth the ninth pick. The Chargers needed an attitude on defense, and the big hitting Turner would've been exactly what they needed
10. Detroit Lions
Herman Moore, WR Virginia
DB Todd Lyght, (1st) Notre Dame
Los Angeles Rams
Defense, defense, defense. The Lions could use help anywhere and everywhere on the D, so Lyght would be the best pick. 
11. New England Patriots
Pat Harlow, OT USC
TE Ben Coates, (5th) Livingstone College
New England Patriots
The Pats lucked their way into getting Coates later in the draft. It would be wise to snap up the Pro Bowl star now, as he probably should've gone even higher than this.
12. Dallas Cowboys
Alvin Harper, WR Tennessee
DT Leon Lett, (7th) Emporia State
Dallas Cowboys
This is a really, really tough decision. Do you take Eric Swann and let Jimmy work with the raw talent, or do you take Lett and let Jimmy work with the even more raw player? It worked out with Lett and this redraft is based on actual production, so he's the pick.
13. Atlanta Falcons
Mike Pritchard, WR Colorado
DB Marty Carter, (8th) MTSU
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
The Falcons desperately, desperately need help in the secondary to help out the solid run defense. Carter would provide instant help, ten years of production and a huge hitting presence.
14. New England Patriots
Leonard Russell, RB Arizona State
DT Chris Zorich, (2nd) Notre Dame
Chicago Bears
The 1990 New England Patriots gave up points in bunches ranking 28th in scoring defense. Zorich is a steady force inside New England could really use. The Pats would pass on Eric Swann even though he's the better prospect.
15. Pittsburgh Steelers
Huey Richardson, LB Florida
LB Roman Phifer, (2nd) UCLA
Los Angeles Rams
The Steelers wanted a linebacker and grabbed the wrong one.
16. Seattle Seahawks
Dan McGwire, QB San Diego State
WR Keenan McCardell, (12th) UNLV
Washington Redskins
Seattle will stick with Dave Kreig, small hands and all, as there aren't any quarterbacks worth mentioning in this draft besides Favre. Seattle could use a game breaking receiver since Brian Blades, Tommy Kane and Jeff Chadwick just aren't exciting anyone. There are several good ones on the board and the Seahawks have to decide between the home run hitting of Alvin Harper or Michael Jackson, the longevity of Keenan McCardell, or the steady production of Jake Reed, Mike Pritchard, Jeff Graham or Yancey Thigpen. Take the long career years of McCardell.
17. Washington Redskins
Bobby Wilson, DT Michigan State
WR Jake Reed, (3rd) Grambling
Minnesota Vikings
The Skins don't need a whole bunch, so they're going with the best player available as a complement to their rapidly aging receiving corps.
18. Cincinnati Bengals
Alfred Williams, LB Colorado
WR Alvin Harper, (1st) Tennessee
Dallas Cowboys
Remember, Cincinnati was a really good team in the early 1990s, but the bottom was about to drop out. The Bengals will need a deep receiver to help out Eddie Brown.
19. Green Bay Packers
Vinnie Clark, DB Ohio State
DB Merton Hanks, (5th) Iowa
San Francisco 49ers
The Brent Fullwood/Darrell Thompson experiment wasn't working out, but there aren't any solid running backs to take. The pass defense could use some help making Hanks a good pick.
20. Dallas Cowboys
Kelvin Pritchett, DT Mississippi
DT Eric Swann, (1st) no college
Arizona Cardinals
We all know now that Swann was a bust as he never coming close to living up to the tag of being, possibly, the next Reggie White. The Cowboys should take him here on the chance (and this isn't the attitude to take with every team in the draft, but this is the fun pick to make) that coaching would've made a difference.
21. Kansas City Chiefs
Harvey Williams, RB LSU
LB/DE Alfred Williams (1st), Colorado
Cincinnati Bengals
Steve DeBerg is NOT going to have a 23 TD, 4 interception year again, but the necessary quarterback the Chiefs are looking for won't be in this draft. Williams was a nice player for several years.
22. Chicago Bears
Stan Thomas, OT Texas
WR Yancey Thigpen, (4th) Winston Salem 
San Diego Chargers
Wendell Davis, Ron Morris, Glen Kozlowski and Tom Waddle could be the worst receiving corps in the NFL. It's between Thigpen, Pritchard and Michael Jackson.
23. Miami Dolphins
Randall Hill, WR Miami
WR Michael Jackson (6th) Southern Miss
Cleveland Browns
The receiving corps is getting really, really old. The Dolphins should go with the best game breaker on the board for Marino to work with. 
24. Los Angeles Raiders
Todd Marinovich, QB USC
RB Howard Griffith (9th), Illinois
Indianapolis Colts
Even with Marcus Allen and the injured Bo Jackson, Griffith fits in perfectly as a great lead blocker. 
25. San Francisco 49ers
Ted Washington, DT Louisville
DE Andy Harmon, (6th) Kent State
Philadelphia Eagles
Harmon would make a great backup for Charles Haley and be a nice addition to a team needing help on the line.
26. Buffalo Bills
Henry Jones, DB Illinois
DB Stanley Richard, (1st) Texas
San Diego Chargers
This is a pick for right now hoping and praying the Bills can get enough talent in the secondary to deal with Art Monk, Gary Clark and the rest of the Redskins in Super Bowl XXVI.
27. New York Giants
Jarrod Bunch, RB Michigan
WR Jeff Graham, (2nd) Ohio State
Pittsburgh Steelers
Not buying into Stephen Baker and Mark Ingram, even though they helped the Giants win the Super Bowl, the pick is to take the decent Graham and plug him in for a decade.